A question for the 12th April march organisers…
By Jen Dodds | February 15th, 2008 | Posted in Uncategorized |
ENGLISH TRANSLATION:
Hello! I’m very happy to see British Deaf people finally taking action and organising a march in London on April 12th. This is great! However, I’d like to clarify what exactly the aim of this march is, please?
You say you are marching against the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Bill, but what I would like to know is … are you against the WHOLE bill or just part of it?I ask this because the Bill is very broad, and has some good things in it too.
For example, it covers gay people’s parenting rights. Like, it says that lesbians can bring up children on their own without men involved. It also says that non-birth mothers in lesbian relationships can put their names on their children’s birth certificate, and other things like that.
These things are good. So if you are against the WHOLE Bill, I am not getting involved!
Please clarify your aim? Thank you!
- 
February 17th, 2008 at 1:58 pm
I agree Jen your point is valid and I too would like to see that the point you had raised about deaf issue - this is what they need to address (part section of the bill and not the whole bill). I thank you for pointing this out.
You hit the nerve your concern the gender/sexuality issues to had raised in your point since this matter is close to your heart and it is of your personal interest being a women.
I was sadden to see some issue from certain BSL lobby that they do not tolerate the wording “deafness” and this then do not validate equality or diversity. Is this hypocritical? This came from the recent Healthy Deaf Mind event.
At times they promote their cultural issue and go down a blind alley forgetting the principles “people”. Is this right Jen? Do help me understand how I can empower myself to have confidence BSL community their proactive work when they struggle in their objectives – their cultural struggles?
Just like my families – I once attend a funeral of my grandma (A dominated Welsh language family).
We are a multicultural family group but they only had Welsh language in this service – excluding other languages and deaf needs. We were disempowering to have any redress this matter. My grandma never once spoken to me in Welsh - this was ironic to feel excluded by a cultural group that I was born into but never nurtured into learning properly the language and the cultural behavioural norm Welsh culture.
I had mirrored this in attuned to Deaf Culture my struggle no fault mine but my peers.I still feel a victim.
I had then made a parallel that this can happen in the deaf community. I had found that this was because they could not tolerate diversity and equality and can be so arrogance in their beliefs to make others feels excluded - Even those who are deaf non BSL users have some affinity feels so – We do have a huge political problem – often not wishing to be involved but want sanity in ourselves and we do have the same yearning and frustration but unable to do so when “language predominate and not deafness” hinders awarness at times.
I wondered why there is no collective spirit within all sectors of our deaf community to show respects our struggles. The fight within - those who hold the power to throw venom and be judgemental attitudinal theirs to discriminate often does happen. I wondered if ever we can achieve our mission to educate our able society who we are and what we wish and have our needs be enabled in our society in order to be an independent person?
February 19th, 2008 at 5:42 am
has someone answered your question yet?
February 19th, 2008 at 11:29 am
Nope still waitinggggggg!!
And in answer to your other question; there is no real answer, but I will ask… if there were no Deaf people, would there be BSL? I think not!
February 25th, 2008 at 8:11 am
[…] awaiting a reply. StopEugenics was not set up to oppose the entire Bill, only the clause (see here for some of the reasons why the whole Bill is not being opposed). Individuals might be against the […]